HomeMy WebLinkAboutArmy Engineers Letter of Permission - PLN General - 9/8/2017 DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMY
SEATTLE DISTRICT,CORPS OF ENGINEERS
P.O.BOX 3755
SEATTLE,WASHINGTON 98424-3766
REPLY TO S
ATTENTION OF EP 0 8 2017
Regulatory Branch
Mr. James and Ms. Joan Hunter ,/
Hunter Family Farm LTD Partnership I / q
h . 9 fy o Sj t0141. 9 U
Reference: NWS-2015-239
Hunter Family Farm LTD
Partnership
Dear Mr. and Ms. Hunter:
We have completed our review of your application for a Department of the Army permit to
construct a joint-use pier,ramp, and float in Hood Canal at Union, Pierce County, Washington.
Based on the information you provided to us,we have determined that Regional General Permit
(RGP) 6,for Structures in Inland Marine Waters of Washington State, authorizes your proposal
as depicted on the enclosed drawings dated January 21, 2016. In order for this RGP
authorization to be valid, you must ensure that the work is performed in accordance with the
requirements and specifications listed in the RGP, in particular those listed in Appendix A of the
RGP.
In order for this RGP to be valid,you must ensure that the work is performed in accordance
with the following special conditions:
a. In order to meet the requirements of the Endangered Species Act and protect Puget Sound
salmonids, Coastal-Puget Sound bull trout, and their prey(surf smelt)you may conduct the
authorized in-water activities from July 16 through September 14 in any year this permit is valid.
If you wish to conduct in-water work from September 15 through February 15, you must,prior to
construction, have a qualified biologist confirm, in writing, that no surf smelt are spawning in the
area. If a Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife(WDFW) Habitat Biologist has
volunteered to conduct a survey as part of the Hydraulic Project Approval,this survey may be
submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers(Corps). The letter or memorandum from the
qualified biologist or the WDFW Habitat Biologist must include the date of the inspection, the
surf smelt findings,and must be provided to the Corps, Seattle District, Regulatory Branch,
FAX (206) 764-6602 (or via email to jason.t.sweeney@usace.army.mil),prior to construction.
Address the letter or memorandum to Mr. Jason Sweeney and include reference number
NWS-2015-239. If the qualified biologist or WDFW Habitat Biologist confirms that no surf
smelt are spawning in the project area, you have one week from the date of the inspection to
2081291 Page 2 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
-2-
complete all work below mean high water. You shall not conduct any in-water activities
authorized by this permit from February 16 through July 15 in any year.
b. In order to meet the requirements of the Endangered Species Act(ESA)programmatic
consultation for Structures in Inland Marine Waters of Washington State(National Marine
Fisheries Reference Number WCR-2016-4361; U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Reference
Number 01EWFW00-2016-F-0565), you must comply with the conditions included in your
application and drawings dated January 21, 2016, in their entirety. If you cannot comply with
the terms and conditions of this programmatic consultation and electronic approval, you must,
prior to commencing construction, contact the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Seattle District,
Regulatory Branch for an individual consultation in accordance with the requirements of the
ESA and/or the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act.
c. You shall implement and abide by the Mitigation Plan for Hunter Family Farm and
James &.loan Hunter Joint-use Pier, Ramp, and Float Project NWS-2015-239 dated
August 28, 2017. Mitigation shall be implemented before or concurrent with the work
authorized by the permit. An as-built report and photographs demonstrating mitigation has been
implemented must be submitted to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Seattle District,
Regulatory Branch,within 12 months from the date of construction completion. You can meet
this reporting requirement by completing and submitting the enclosed Report for Mitigation
Work Completion form.
d. To insure that light transmission is not impacted, grating must not be covered with or
blocked by any objects, such as, but not limited to,buildings,planters, storage sheds or boxes,
nets, carpets, boards, tables, lawn furniture, kayaks, SUPs, or utility conduits or boxes.
General Condition 3, Deed Restriction, requires that a copy of this verification letter,permit
drawings, mitigation plan is recorded with the local government within 60 days from the date of
this letter. You must submit proof of the deed restriction to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
(Corps) within 65 days from the date of this letter.
Please remember that a report on mitigation completion or a status report must be submitted
to the Corps within 12 months from the date of this letter. We recommend that you complete
and submit a Status Report.for Mitigation Work Completion to meet this requirement. Also,
monitoring reports of the riparian mitigation planting area are due annually for 5 years from the
date the Corps accepts the as-built drawings. We recommend that you complete and submit a
Riparian Mitigation Planting Monitoring Report to meet this requirement. These report
templates in italicized text can be found on our webpage at www.nws.usace.army.mil, select
Regulatory—Regulatory/Permits, select Forms.
This permit expires on April 20, 2022. Activities that have commenced (e.g.,are under
construction)or are under contract to commence in reliance upon this permit will remain
2081291 Page 3 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
-3-
authorized provided that the activity is completed within one year of the date of this permit's
expiration, modification,or revocation, unless discretionary authority has been exercised on a
case-by-case basis to modify, suspend,or revoke the authorization.
A copy of this letter with permit drawings will be furnished to Ms. Meg Amos, Marine
Surveys and Assessments, 267 Hudson Street, Port Townsend, Washington 98368. If you have
any questions about your authorization or our regulatory program, please contact
Mr. Jason Sweeney at jason.t.sweeney@usace.army.mil or by phone at (206) 764-3450.
Sincerely,
Thomas D. Bloxton,Jr., Project Manager
Regulatory Branch
Enclosures
2081291 Page 4 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
i
Figure 3. Plan view of the proposed structure
DRAFT 115'STRUCTURE
HUNTER FAMILY PROJECT HOOD CANAL
Jon 15,2016
One of tow
10'diomoter
901r.steel pilings ED I
30' One of two
• 8'diomefer
At least Sox
Mil,Piles
�
functionolgrlatirg
in the frosts
o' to, 25' SO'
Akrmirum romp with
100%greti ng
35'
One of four
5'diometer
Pier Piles
115'
100y grottd
alumina Pier
50'
PIER
6'
MHHW=11.8'
15 ONE FOOT UP
THE BULKHEAD
ROCK BULKHEA
2'X b'CONCRETE PAD
UNDER PIER `y
12' 22'
SR 106 Row
Nws -Zois- 239
Purpose:On Water recreation Applicant:Hunter Family Farm LTD. Propoacd:Joint use pier,ramp and
Datum:C.0'MLLW Partnership and James d Joan Hurter float
Job Name Hunter Family Farm LTD. In:Hood Canal
Adjacent Property Owners: Partnership and James 8 Joan Hunter Joint-
(1)John 6 Joan Peaenpaugh.225M the Pier,Ramp and Float Project At:N 48.357552• W 123,014403,
87"'Place W. Edmonds,WA MM Refererm": County:Mason
12)Daniel&Jill Sullivan.18010 Viking Job Add:9894 E.SR 106,Union.WA 98582 p"ft Jan.21,2018
Way NVV.Pouisbo,WA 98370 Mall Add:Sarre as job address Page: 3 of 8
AASftik Hunter Family Farm and James&t Joan Hunter Joint-Use Pier Ramp and Float Project.
2081291 Page 5 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
Hunter Project
NWS 2015-00239
Mitigation Item#1: Buoys to be Removed Details
Buoy# 1
Lat 47.3579930
Long-123.014668°.
109' from shore
Size=tire filled with concrete—about 1 cu ft
Buoy#2
Lat 47.3581190
Long-123.0151000'
212' from shore
Size=2' by 2' by 2' concrete block (8 cu ft)
Buoy#3
Lat 47.357755'
Long -123.015273'
156' from shore
Size=55 gal. Barrel (approx. 24" in diameter—7.35 cu ft)
2081291 Page 6 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
a
Mitigation Items # 2 and 3:
Removing Old Marine Railway Footings
& 10'x10' Float
0' 25'
10' 50'
Tl T2 T3 T4 T5 T6 T7 T8 T9 T20 T11
10F 1OF 20F 10F 10F 10F 1OF 10F LOG
106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 105 1�0
Los 10 S 205 206 105 205 205 205 105 LOS
10F 20F 20F 30F 10F 10F 106
106 106 105 105 106 10G 106 106
10�S 105 10F 1OF 105 105105 160
�- 1 20 F 30 F 10 6 10 6 ` '�' -4.3
20F 20F to 10F 106 106 I I0
1� ...! l :, 6 10
"I"" f06 206 Approximate
210 F. 10 F 30 F 1 � !Oat location
1 NO 14010'x19
"Now 106
1s E6T 20 -3.3
�.■ 10 F
30 F
1 1-30 10 F 120
100 MACROAL6AE AND
0.7 %COVERAGE PER
M=SQUARE METER:
F Filamentous Reds
6=6racilaria
- S.=S. latissima
80
3.2
- Number and
' E&T=
number of Zostera
t sz Marina turions
r 60
=5.9usz s 4.7 NOTE;Only macroalone
PProx at %covera Of
or greater are seen
}r•
�., on this map.
40
.ik 6.6
20
t a 8.3
Distance along T6
F and tidal elevation
(MLLW)in feet
Concrete bases from old marine 10.0
rai I way
14" w x 7" d x 6' long
Some are at or below
beach level
Approximately 62.9 square feet of concrete debris
2081291 Page 7 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
r . L
Figure 2. Site plan
0' 26 75• PROPOSED
LOCATION FOR
10, 50' 10(y •E HEM SCREW
ANCHOR FOR
MOORIN6 BUOY
HOOD CANAL
JOHN&JOAN DANIEL 6 JILL
PECKENPAUGH SULLIVAN
22520 87TH PL W. 18010 VIKTNG WA NW
EDMONDS. WA POULSBO,WA
98026 PE tls f om b��heaNNF+r w—� 98370
#32236-50-00006 PL #32236-51-00036
PL PL
PROPOSED
JOINT USE
APPIZOx STRUCTURE APP20X.
ear 127'
MrIHW=11.8'(MLLW)
15 1'UP THE BULKHEAD
{ BU H A
2'x 6'concrete pod 22'
under pier 2•
ROW
30'
FOG LINE
SR 106 CENTER LINE
JOINT USE APPLICANTS
f
JAMES 6 JOAN HUNTER HUNTER FAMILY FARM LTD.PARTNERSHIP
PO BOX 2049 9894 E,SR 106,UNION,WA
SHELTON,WA 98584 #32236-50-00010
#32236-50-00007
PL PL NOTE: This is not a survey.
All measurements are approx. Pt
Contractor should vari all
measurements before coristruction.
Purpose.On water recreation Applicant Hunter Family Farm LTD Proposed:Joint-usa pier,ramp and
Datum:0.0'MLLVU Partnership and James 8 Joan Hunter float
Job Name'Hunter Family Farm LTD, In:Hood Carnil `
Adjacent Property Owners: Partnership and James 8 Joan Huller Joint-
(1)John S Joan Peckanpaugh 22520 Use Pier,Ramp and Float Project At N 48.357552°W 123.014403
Or Place W.,Edmonds,WA 98022 Referonc.# N W 3— 2015—2 3 County:Mason
(2)Daniel d Jill Sullivan.18010 Viking Job Add:9894 E SR 106,Union,WA 98592 Date:Jan 21,2016
Way NW,Poulabo,WA 98370 Mail Add:Same as job address Page:2 of 8
MSFxA Hunter Family Farm and James 8t Joan Hunter Joint-Use Pier Ramp and Float Project. '
2081291 Page 8 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
Mitigation Item# 4:
Planting Plan
August 28, 2017
Total Planted Area=Approximately 1440 ft2
Mitigation Planting and Monitoring Plan for Hunter Family
A. Mitigation Plan
Mitigation is required for this site as the proposed structure will be built on a shoreline of statewide
significance and will impact critical habitats.Native plants will be installed along the top of the top of the
bulkhead replacing the grass which continues from the road to the edge of the bulkhead. The planting
plan area can be seen in Figure 1 (planting plan map)and in Figure 2 (photos). Plants will be installed in
a 6 foot by 240 foot area just above the bulkhead. Nootka Roses will be installed at 4 foot centers for
approximately 240 feet skipping the area in front of the proposed structure. Other species will be
interspersed. The plants selected for this site are all native plants that can tolerate salt spray from the
marine environment. They were selected to improve the overall value of the functions in this critical area
buffer. Soil stability,nutrient input, and wildlife habitat were all important factors. Following is a table
showing the plant species and numbers for the planting area. Plants will be selected from a regional
native plant nursery.
Plant List
Quantity Botanical Name Common Name Size
36 Rosa Nutkana Nootka Rose 2 Gal
4 olodiscus discolor Ocean spray 2 Gal
8 Ribes sanguineumRed-Flowering Currant 2 Gal
6 Vaccinium ovatum Evergreen Huckleberry 2 Gal
m'
12 evmus mollis Dunegrass l Gal
10 Gaultheria shallop Sala] 1 Gal
Plants should be installed in late fall or early spring following the construction work. During these times
plant are semi-dormant and soils are easier to work. Plants will be laid out by hand generally following
the spacing specified on the planting plan map (Figure 1). The plants will be installed by digging a one to
two foot hole, loosening the soil, placing the plant in the ground after loosening soil around the root ball.
The hole must be deep enough to ensure the roots are straight,but not so deep as to bury plants too far
above the root collar. Once the plant is in place, the hole will be backfilled and tamped lightly. Mulch
should be applied 3" deep around plants,being careful not to touch the stem of the plant.No
extraordinary measures are proposed at this time to protect installed plants other than mulching,weeding
and watering. Substitutions might be necessary for species or individuals that cannot be found at local
2081291 Page 9 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
r
nurseries. All plant substitutions will be approved by the project biologist prior to installation to ensure
their suitability for the site.
B. Performance Standards
Performance standards are measurable criteria for determining if the goals and objectives of the
mitigation project are being achieved. If the proposed benchmarks are not achieved by comparing the
surveys to the mitigation goals, then contingency plans will need to be implemented.
Performance Standard#1 (survival rate): Immediately after planting, all plants will be counted and
documented. At the end of each growing season(late Aug-early Sept)plots will be visited and a count of
surviving plants will be documented. The percent survival for the plots will be calculated by dividing the
total number of plants after planting by the total number of surviving plants at the end of the season.
Photo stations for the replanting site will be determined and a photograph of each transplant location will
be taken on an annual basis. Individual plants that die must be replaced with native species I order to
meet the survival performance standards.
Performance Standard#2 (percent cover): The percent cover standard will be monitored by looking at
each monitoring unit of the enhanced areas from above and estimating the area covered by the individual
species. The percent cover within an area can be quantified as a total greater than 100%because plants
(in tree,high/low shrub and herbaceous layers) overlap uncover.
C. Monitoring Plan
An as-built drawing and report will be submitted as documentation of the implementation of the approved
planting plan within one month of installation. The plan will include vegetation description and photo
documentation from established photo stations. A panoramic photo of the entire mitigation site will also
be provided. Photos should be taken June-August, during the growing season. Monitoring will take
place over a period of five years at the end of the growing season (late August or early September)of
each monitoring year. The performance standards will be monitored by measuring plots in zones within
the planting area that will be established and mapped after planting occurs, on the as-built plan. There
will be photo points for each plot and they will be referenced on the as-built plan. Each year, the photo
points established at each site will be used for comparison. Photos will be taken at all points for all years
as visual documentation of the performance standard's progress, or lack thereof. In addition to photos at
designated points,photo documentation must include a panoramic view of the entire planting area.
Submitted photos must be formatted on standard 8 1/2"by I I" paper, dated with the date the photo was
taken and clearly labeled with the direction from which the photo was taken. The photo location points
must be identified on an appropriate drawing. Collected data and photos will be compiled into an annual
Riparian Planting Report each year and submitted by November 30 of each monitoring year for five
years. Each annual monitoring report shall include written and photographic documentation on plant
mortality and replanting efforts and must document whether the performance standards are being met.
Monitoring results will determine whether or not contingency measures will be needed.
Performance Standards#1 & 2
Year 1: Achieve 100% survival success of replanted natives into mitigation areas.
Year 2: Achieve 100% survival success at end of second year into mitigation areas.
Year 3: Achieve 80%survival success at end of third year into mitigation areas.
2081291 Page 10 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
t
Year 4: Achieve 80%survival success at end of fourth year into mitigation areas.
Year 5: Achieve 80%survival success at end of into mitigation areas.
D. Maintenance and Contingency
Maintenance shall occur at least twice during the growing season to ensure the survival of all native
species within the mitigation area, including volunteer natives.Watering by hand or sprinkler may be
necessary during year number one until the plants are established. Water requirements will depend on the
timing of planting with the seasons and weather conditions. Once plants are established, extra watering
may not be necessary. Hand weeding will be necessary around all plants that are being monitored to
ensure survival and coverage. if the required rate is not met by the end of any monitoring year,plants lost
to mortality will be replaced to achieve the percentage cover called for in the performance standard
described above. Prior to replacement,an appropriate assessment will be performed to determine if the
survival was affected by species/site selection, animal damage, or some other factor. Subsequent
contingency actions must be designed to respond directly to the stressor(s), which are increasing
mortality of planted native species. If a particular species is shown not to endure site conditions then
another, more appropriate species will be selected. If excessive damage is observed,protective measures
will be introduced. Monitoring years may be added if significant replanting becomes necessary.
Monitoring on an annual basis for five years will occur with photographs to determine the survival rate of
the transplanted area. If 100%success is achieved during the first two years or 80%success rate during
the last three years, monitoring will continue without extra replanting efforts. Within the five year time
period, transplanting will occur on an annual basis to replace any plants that are lost until 80%success is
achieved.
2081291 Page 11 of 12 09/25/2017 12:50:58 PM Mason County, WA
Figure 1. Site location
.^L:-^:ti:U'••Y` ..- •'3 L•J+i• .••• iVL�1.`Y•1 'Ll•.•iV 1.'
Dack
Jr,
15-VkTS-C 1-0el
_ i IF*t�k
l ,fir
i 16T
PROJECT SITE
4 0 •l.J�
fe
TxE
r rEET
' P1�i!ed!tr-"OPO!y`:4S�S1`iiD,rnePrnl�.{iowiR-a-.•r;pp.p��
Purpose:On water recreation Applicant:Hunter Family Farm LTD. Proposed.Joint-use pier,ramp and
Datum:0.0'MLLW Partnership and James&Joan Hunter float
Job Name:Hunter Family Farm LTD. In:Hood Canal
Adjacent Property Owners: Partnership and James&Joan Hunter Joint-
(1)John&Joan Peekenpaugh.22520 p oat
Use Pier.Ram and Float Project At:N 48.3575521 W 123.014403'
870 Place W..Edmonds.WA 98022 Reference# NWS—201- —2 3 9 County:Mason
(2)Daniel&Jill Sullivan.18010 Viking Job Add:9894 E.SR 106,Union,WA 98592 Date:Jan.21,2016
Way NW.Poulsbo,WA 96370 Mail Add:Same as job address Page:1 of 8
MSEtA Hunter Family Farm and James&Joan Hunter Joint-Use Pier Ramp and Float Project-
Figure 2. Site plan
0' 25• 75' PROPOSED
LOCATION FOR
10, 50, 100, •-—HELIX SCREW
ANCHORFOR
MOORING BUOY
HOOD CANAL
125'
JOHN&JOAN DANIEL&JILL
PECKENPAUGH SULLIVAN
22520 87TH PL W. 18010 VIKING WA NW
EDMONDS,WA POULSBO,WA
98026 D1 115'frombulkhead/MHFIW_�,. - #3223983700036
#32236-50-00006
I I
PL PL
PROPOSED
JOINT USE
APPROX. STRUCTURE APPROX.
20U 12T
MHHW=11.8'(MLLW)
IS r LP THE BULKHEAD
W BULKHEA
CCV
�oc ,,co ms 11
2'x 6'concrete pod 22•
under pier 2•
ROW
30'
— — — —FOG LINE
SR 106 CENTER LINE
JOINT USE APPLICANTS
JAMES&JOAN HUNTER HUNTER FAMILY FARM LTD.PARTNERSHIP
PO BOX 2049 9894 E.SR 106,UNION,WA
SHELTON,WA 98584 #32236-50-00010
#32236-50-00007
PL PL NOTE: This is not a survey.
All measurements are approx. PL
Contractor should verify all
measurements before construction.
Purpose:On water recreation Applicant Hunter Family Farm LTD. Proposed:Joint-use pier,ramp and
Datum:0.0 MLLW Partnership and James&Joan Hunter float
Job Name:Hunter Family Farm LTD. In:Hood Canal
Adjacent Property Owners: Partnership and James&Joan Hunter Joint-
(1)John&Joan Peckenpaugh,22520 Use Pier,Ramp and Float Project At:N 48.357552°W 123.014403,
87"Place W.,Edmonds,WA 98022 Reference* N W3- 20{5•—2 11 County:Mason
(2)Daniel&Jill Sullivan.18010 Uking Job Add:9894 E.SR 106,Union.WA 98592 Date:Jan 21,2016
Way NW,Poulsbo,WA 98370 Mail Add:Same as job address Paga:2 of 8
MS&A Hunter Family Farm and James Et Joan Hunter Joint Use Pier Ramp and Float Project.
�' A try, •
boa
PF
RECEIVED
15,
AM
WHO
PROJECT SI�T�
s _
i
0' 25` 75' 1D Nootka Rose
10' 50' 100' Red Flowering Currant /V
' Oceanspray
PL115 from bulkhead/MHHW Q
Dunegrass 3:
r Evergreen Huckleberry >
Salal
PL °
U
c
~' O
PROPOSED
{--JOINT USE
STRUCTURE
a
00
LO
n U)
N
MHHW = 11.8' (MLLW) r
15 I' UP THE BULKHEAD ►�
BULKHEAD �' � o
LO
4 rp
.�
ROW T
30' N
-- FOG LINE
5R 106 CENTER LINECD
a
N
r
Co
O
N